Influence of various factors on individual radiation exposure from the chernobyl disaster
© Zamostian et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2002
Received: 18 July 2002
Accepted: 29 October 2002
Published: 29 October 2002
The explosion at the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant was one of the greatest known nuclear disasters of the 20th century. To reduce individual exposure to ionizing radiation the Soviet Union government introduced a number of counter-measures. This article presents a description of how historical events conspired to disrupt these efforts and affect residents in exposed areas.
This study employed an extensive review of data on radionuclide deposition, contamination patterns and lifestyle characteristics. Data were obtained from the Ukraine Ministry of Health and the Ukraine Research Center for Radiation Medicine.
Data are presented on annual contamination rates in selected locales as well as data on local food consumption patterns. Historical factors including economic and political circumstances are also highlighted. Results show the diminution of individual doses between 1987 and 1991 and then an increase between 1991 and 1994 and the relationship between this increase and changes in the lifestyle of the local population.
A number of factors played direct and indirect roles in contributing to the populace's cumulative radiation exposure. Future post-contamination studies need to consider these factors when estimating individual exposures.
The Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant accident can be differentiated from other radiation accidents not only by its magnitude but also by its transcontinental impact and the unique patterns of radionuclide fallout. It is estimated that more than four million people in the Ukraine alone were exposed. Unlike the atomic bomb detonation, exposures from Chernobyl were different and subtler . Rather than high-energy external exposure, the vast majority of individuals received on-going, low-dose exposures owing to the presence of long-lived radionuclides such as cesium (Cs), strontium (Sr) and plutonium (Pu) in their food supply. These exposures and the government's response to minimize their effect were further complicated by the interplay of economic and political factors resulting from the dissolution of the Soviet Union.
This report describes the dynamics of these factors in a specific region of Ukraine where the population received significant internal doses of radiation due to consumption of radioactively contaminated food and where these exposures, and thereby their health risks, appear to have been exacerbated by the dissolution of the Soviet Union and subsequent disruption of protective counter-measures.
Characteristics of the study region
The Rivno Oblast, located approximately 250–300 km from the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant, is one of the more interesting areas within the Ukrainian Polissia. Levels of 137Cs soil deposition did not exceed 200 kBq·m-2, and levels of 90Sr and 238–240Pu depositions were negligible. Because of these "low" levels of exposure, this area was not officially considered "radioactively contaminated" by the Chernobyl accident. Detailed studies of this area, therefore, were not begun until 1987–1988, when unusually high levels of 137Cs were detected transferring from soil to plants and through the ecological chain to animals and people. The local environment also has peat-swampy soil that is characterized by the highest values of soil-to-milk transfer coefficients.
In addition, the rayons of the Rivno Oblast may be characterized by unique socioeconomic characteristics and farm-management practices. Residents tend to live in small villages surrounded by forests. Family size tends to be moderately large (3 to 5 children). The main food sources are locally produced (vegetables, milk) and/or include foods that can be foraged from the forests (mushrooms, berries and wild game) and swamps (cranberries). These wild foods are known to most readily concentrate radioactive elements (particularly 137Cs). It is estimated that approximately 90 percent of the total lifetime radiation dose to individuals in the population is due to internal exposure to radiation from radiocesium ingested in contaminated foodstuffs .
Radiation exposure measurements and dose estimates
Radioactive contamination of the Rokitnovsky Rayon, Rivno Oblast
Standard deviation, kBq·m-2
An individual's dose is calculated based on external (direct exposure) and internal exposures (i.e., consumption of milk and wild foods). Of particular interest in this discussion is internal exposure. It is possible to estimate internal exposures from radiocesium ingestion within a particular population by considering the concentration of 137 Cs in the human diet over different periods of time . This concentration is determined by the radioecological conditions at the place where the foodstuffs were produced (137Cs soil deposition and its soil-transfer factor) and dietary patterns (i.e., frequency, quantity of particular foodstuffs such as milk, mushrooms, etc.).
Radiological monitoring for internal exposure may be accomplished in two ways: 1) monitoring of radionuclide body burden by whole body counters (WBCs); or 2) monitoring of radionuclide concentrations in various foodstuffs and their reported consumption. Continuous WBCs of radiocesium body burden across gender and among different age groups and seasons of year is the most accurate way to estimate internal exposure [4, 5], but surveillance is often complicated and time consuming. While measurement of radiocesium concentration in locally produced foodstuffs provides information on the relative contribution of specific food items, it is quite difficult to determine individual values and often impractical.
Contamination of locally produced milk
In the Ukrainian population, milk is widely consumed by both children and adults since it is readily available throughout the year in all areas. Milk is also a significant source of internal exposure due to its concentration of radiocesium. According to the results of dietary studies in the northern part of Rivno Oblast [4, 6] approximately 70–75% of daily 137Cs intake is due to consumption of locally produced milk and milk products; about 10–15% may be attributed to forest mushroom and berry consumption and about 10–15% due to potato and vegetable consumption. Thus, consumption of locally produced milk appears to represent the most important factor in determining internal radiocesium exposure. Although forest mushrooms and berries are highly contaminated with 137Cs, most of the internal exposure resulted from milk consumption due to the prevalence of milk consumption in this population.
A number of countermeasures were initiated after the Accident. The goal of these activities was to reduce the population's internal exposure to radionuclides such as 131I in the short-term and 137Cs in the long-term. The most significant countermeasures included governmental prohibitions of consuming locally produced milk and foodstuffs, warnings against consumption of wild foods (mushrooms and berries) use of "clean areas" for farming and pastures where improvements had been applied and application of Cs binders to animal foods. In addition, the government distributed foods from uncontaminated areas to the residents of contaminated areas. The success of these counter measures was likely non-uniform and varied by oblast as well as by type of farm (collective vs. private). The long-term success of this strategy depended on continuous governmental support and compliance among residents within the affected areas. According to a report by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), the application of countermeasures led to significant reductions in radiocesium contamination of milk and meat produced on State and collective farms . They note, however, that many of the countermeasures were difficult to apply by small-scale farmers for economic reasons thus affording significant proportions of the population with little protection.
Ionizing radiation exposure assessment or biomonitoring
In the selected settlements of Vezhitsia, Drozdyn, Perehodichi and Stare Selo approximately 20–80 milk samples were collected each year during pasture season (spring through autumn). Concentration of 137Cs and 134Cs was determined in these milk samples by means of gamma-spectrometry measurements. As demonstrated by Figure 2, while there is variation in the concentration of 137Cs in milk in different areas of the Rokitnovsky region, there is a significant decline in 137Cs milk concentrations over time. The former may be attributed to a number of factors such as the actual radioactive contamination of the territory (Table 1) as well as differences in environmental conditions (soil types, landscapes, etc.) that affect the transfer of 137Cs from the soil. For example, the transfer factor of 137Cs from soil to milk in 1991–1992 was in the range from 0.3 to 20 Bq·L-2 per kBq·m-2.. The soil transfer factor is the most important parameter in determining 137Cs concentration in locally produced milk. The villages of Vezhitsia, Drozdyn, Perehodichi and Stare Selo exhibited the highest soil-to-milk transfer coefficients. For 1991–1992, recorded values were 19.9 Bq·L-2 per kBq·m-2 in Vezhitsia, 19.4 Bq·L-2 per kBq·m-2 in Drozdyn, 9.9 Bq·L-2 per kBq·m-2 in Perehodichi and 17.4 Bq·L-2 per kBq·m-2 Bq-L-2 in Stare Selo. High transfer factors coupled with other local characteristics (e.g., proximity to forests and swamps, availability of cultivated pastures for cows) make these areas the most critical from the standpoint of internal exposure in nearby residents. From 1988 through 1991, the mean concentration in milk (for all of Rokitnovsky) decreased by more than 4 fold and by 1996 nearly 10-fold. Decrements of similar magnitude have been reported by other investigators [9, 10]. No further decrease was observed for the period 1996 through 2000. Given that milk is an important contributor of radiocesium intake for rural people as previously described, decreases in environmental contamination levels would be paralleled by decreases in the local population's internal dose.
Whole body counts
Beginning in 1987, the Ukrainian government-monitoring program in the radioactively contaminated areas initiated direct body burden measurements of radiocesium using WBCs among Rokitnovsky residents . About 16,000 WBCs were performed among different age groups, with approximately 7000 measurements among adults. The majority of these were performed in the field by the Research Center for Radiation Medicine (RCRM) using mobile whole body counters while some were performed in the central laboratory at the RCRM in Kiev. Regardless, all measurements were made using similar methodology and are considered equally valid. It should be noted that the number of measurements performed each year did vary. Individuals were selected from each settlement. The typical annual number of measurements in each settlement was 50–100, which corresponds to 10–20% of the adult population in each settlement. However there were some years when only 10 measurements were made in a given settlement while in other years 300–400 measurements were made.
A myriad of factors are known to contribute to individual Chernobyl-related ionizing radiation exposure. Chief among these is direct environmental contamination from the accident based on prevailing wind patterns, type of housing, amount of time spent outdoors, etc. Other factors include those that affect levels of internal exposure such as soil types (soil-to-milk transfer factors) and consumption patterns of contaminated foods (locally produced and wild). While these factors directly contribute to individual exposures, they are also subject to the influence of external forces. The confluence of economic (collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991), environmental (fallout patterns and local soil-to-milk transfer ratios) and sociological (local food consumption patterns) factors resulted in significant variations in individual exposure.
Radionuclide fallout from the Chernobyl reactor explosion and the ensuing graphite fire contaminated vast areas of land, most of which was agricultural. The immediate governmental response was the destruction of livestock and food crops within the contaminated areas. Counter-measures were then introduced by the Soviet Union government that included shipments of uncontaminated milk and foods into these areas so as to reduce individual exposure and associated health risks. If these countermeasures were not introduced and people continued to consume locally produced foodstuffs, levels of Dint of 137Cs would have continued unabated and the populace's only hope would have been time, the time it would take for the natural elimination of 137Cs from the ecosystem. And time is not an ally. While the half-life of 137Cs in agricultural products is 2.8–5.6 years, it is approximately 10 years for berries and 20 years for mushrooms . Fesenko, et al. studied twenty-seven rural settlements to assess the effectiveness of countermeasures. They observed an initial decrease of up to 40% of doses with a gradual diminution of effect over time.
Introduction of countermeasures such as the provision of non-contaminated foodstuffs from 1988 until 1991, resulted in decreases of 137Cs exposures based upon biomonitoring and WBC data in the Rokitnovsky Rayon by more than two-fold. Similar decreases were documented in other villages, such as in Perehodichi and Vezhitsia, where levels dropped nearly four fold. After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, values of Dint in these areas rapidly increased and approximated values registered in the immediate post-accident period.
A plausible explanation for the increase in Dint relates to the severe economic strains brought on by the dissolution of the Soviet Union and a cessation of government sponsored counter-measures. The collapse of the FSU, which was accompanied by high unemployment and economic hardship, led to a reversion to traditional diets. People were forced to once again consume more locally produced food as well as "free" natural foods from the forests (mushrooms, berries, wild game, etc.). Moreover, after a relatively short period of time, it is likely that people became indifferent to warnings of the possible harm from radiation and to recommendations about the consumption of these foods. The influence of these factors is especially strong in those villages located in the forest area, where wild foods are a traditional mainstay of the local diet. Radiological contamination is tasteless, odorless and invisible. It is only natural that after the "immediate" crisis passed more people were more concerned with the immediate effects of hunger rather than any possible long-term health effects.
We have related how a number of factors contributed to individual exposures among residents of the Polissia Region in Ukraine. Contrary to initial expectations that food management practices, effective counter-measures, and time would result in decreased internal exposure from 137Cs, this did not occur possibly due to social and economic forces active in the study region. The economic crisis that occurred in the Ukrainian part of the Former Soviet Union after 1990 likely contributed to increased internal doses from 137Cs owing to consumption of locally produced and wild foods (mushrooms, berries, wild game, etc.).
In the absence of serial WBCs, individual exposure can only be estimated based on environmental sampling and personal interviews. Future post-contamination studies need to include continuous monitoring of both the radiation content of locally produced foodstuffs and patterns of consumption. Moreover, efforts should include periodic population surveys to assess changes in dietary behaviors, agricultural practices, politico-economic issues, and other factors that could affect internal dose estimates. Only on the basis of such information will it be possible to reasonably plan, implement and evaluate effective protective programs aimed at reducing exposures and to affect the subsequent risk of morbidity and mortality.
List of Abbreviations
Becquerel Cs :Cesium
- Dint :
Internal effective doses
International Atomic Energy Agency
Research Center for Radiation Medicine
Whole body count
"This work was supported by Grant #N00014-94-1-0049 issued to Georgetown University from the Office of Naval Research in support of the International Consortium for Research on the Health Effects of Radiation. The contents are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the Office of Naval Research or Georgetown University."
- Weinberg AD, Kripalani S, McCarthy PL, Schull WJ: Caring for survivors of the Chernobyl disaster. What the clinician should know. Jama. 1995, 274: 408-12. 10.1001/jama.274.5.408.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ten years after the accident at Chernobyl NPP. Ukraine national report. Kiev: Ministry of Chernobyl of Ukraine. 1996
- United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation: Exposures and Effects of the Chernobyl Accident. In: Sources and Effects of Ionizing Radiation Volume II Effects. 2000, United Nations Press, 485-Google Scholar
- Likhtarev IA, Kovgan LN, Vavilov SE, Gluvchinsky RR, Perevoznikov ON, Litvinets LN, Anspaugh LR, Kercher JR, Bouville A: Internal exposure from the ingestion of foods contaminated by 137Cs after the Chernobyl accident. Report 1. General model: ingestion doses and countermeasure effectiveness for the adults of Rovno Oblast of Ukraine. Health Phys. 1996, 70: 297-317.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Perevoznikov ON, Likhtarev IA, Litvinets LA, Jakovleva G: Experience, problems and results of mass implementation of whole-body counters at post-Chernobyl period. In: Assessment of the health and environmental impact from radiation doses due to released radionuclides: proceedings of an international workshop at Chiba; Chiba. 1994, 129-139.Google Scholar
- Korzun VN, Stepanova EI, Torbin VF: Ionizing radiation and child nutrition. Kiev: Chornobylinterinform. 1997Google Scholar
- Guidelines for Agricultural Countermeasures following an Accidental Release of Radionuclides: IAEA Technical Reports Series, No. 363. 1994
- Dosimetry passportization of the settlements of Ukraine located at the territories radioactively affected after Chernobyl accident, Catalog 5. Kiev: Ministry for health protection of Ukraine; (in Russian). 1995
- Sanzharova NI, Fesenko SV, Aleksahin RM, Anisimov VS, Kuznetsov LG, Chernyaeva LG: Changes in the forms of 137Cs and its availability for plants as dependent on properties of fallout after the Chernobyl nuclear power plant accident. Sci Total Environ. 1994, 154: 9-22. 10.1016/0048-9697(94)90609-2.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Muck K: Longterm reduction of caesium concentration in milk after nuclear fallout. Sci Total Environ. 1995, 162: 63-73. 10.1016/0048-9697(95)04322-R.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Shutov VN, Bruk GY, Basalaeva LN, Vasilevetskiy VA, Ivanova NP, Karlin IS: The role of mushrooms and berries in the formation of internal exposure doses to the population of Russia after the Chernobyl Accident. Rad Prot Dos. 1996, 67: 55-64.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fesenko S, Jacob P, Alexakhin R, Sanzharova NI, Panov A, Fesenko G, Cecille L: Important factors governing exposure of the population and countermeasure application in rural settlements of the Russian Federation in the long-term after the Chernobyl accident. J Environ Radioact. 2001, 56: 77-98. 10.1016/S0265-931X(01)00048-0.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Likhtarev IA, Kovgan LN, Vavilov SE, Perevoznikov ON, Litvinets LN, Anspaugh LR, Jacob P, Prohl G: Internal exposure from the ingestion of foods contaminated by 137Cs after the Chernobyl accident–report 2. Ingestion doses of the rural population of Ukraine up to 12 y after the accident (1986–1997). Health Phys. 2000, 79: 341-57.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/content/backmatter/1476-069x-1-4-b1.pdf
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article: verbatim copying and redistribution of this article are permitted in all media for any purpose, provided this notice is preserved along with the article's original URL.