Skip to main content

Table 3 Assessment of risk of bias in included studies

From: Psychosocial and demographic predictors of adherence and non-adherence to health advice accompanying air quality warning systems: a systematic review

Author

Selection bias

Detection bias

Reporting bias

Other sources of bias

Evans et al. [26]

L

M

M

L

Hartill [24]

H

M

H

H

Johnson [27]

M

M

H

L

Johnson [28]

M

M

M

L

Kentucky Health Issues Poll [34]

H

M

H

L

Kilbane-Dawe et al. [35]

H

M

H

L

Licskai et al. [39]

H

H

H

H

Lyons et al. [36]

L

L

L

L

Mak, et al. [43]

H

M

H

L

Mansfield et al. [33]

L

M

M

L

Laube [38]

M

M

M

H

McDermott et al. [25]

H

M

H

L

Radisic, et al. [41] (qualitative)

M

L

L

L

Radisic et al. [40]

M

M

H

L

Reams et al. [29]

H

H

H

M

Semenza et al. [30]

M

M

H

L

Skov et al. [15]

L

M

H

L

Smallbone [37]

H

M

H

L

Stieb et al. [42]

M

H

H

L

Sugerman et al. [31]

L

M

M

L

Wen et al. [32]

M

M

L

L

  1. H high risk of bias, M moderate risk of bias, L low risk of bias, N/A not applicable