Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of criteria of analysis with assigned point values used in the evaluation of statistical plausibility of an NMDR relationship

From: Non-monotonic dose-response relationships and endocrine disruptors: a qualitative method of assessment

Number of doses below ZEP (excluding the control)

Score A

1

1

2

2

3

3

4

4

≥5

5

Experimental determination of ZEP

Score B

Yes

1

No

0

Number of doses statistically different from control

Score C

1

2

2

4

3

8

≥4

16

Reproducibility of the dose-response relationship

Score D

Yes

3

No

0

Magnitude of response (percentage control value)

Score E a

Inverted-U curve

U curve

 

≥100%, ≤125%

≤97%, ≥92%

0,5

>125%, ≤150%

<92%, ≥84%

1

>150%, ≤200%

<84%, ≥68%

2

>200%, ≤400%

<68%, ≥5%

3

>400%

<5%

4

  1. aThe point value is multiplied by the number of experimental doses falling within the corresponding percentage range.
  2. Criteria reported (Table 1) were extracted from Calabrese and Baldwin [12]. The ZEP (zero equivalent point) corresponds to the point where the response crosses the control value in a hormetic effect.