- Open Access
Effects of long-term low-level radiation exposure after the Chernobyl catastrophe on immunoglobulins in children residing in contaminated areas: prospective and cross-sectional studies
Environmental Health volume 13, Article number: 36 (2014)
After the Chernobyl nuclear incident in 1986, children in the Narodichesky region, located 80 km west of the Chernobyl Power Plant, were exposed to 137Cesium (137Cs). Little is known about the effects of chronic low-level radiation on humoral immune responses in children residing in contaminated areas.
In four different approaches we investigated the effect of residential 137Cs exposure on immunoglobulins A, G, M, and specific immunoglobulin E in children. In a dynamic cohort (1993–1998) we included 617 children providing 2,407 repeated measurements; 421 and 523 children in two cross-sectional samples (1997–1998 and 2008–2010, respectively); and 25 participants in a small longitudinal cohort (1997–2010). All medical exams, blood collections, and analyses were conducted by the same team. We used mixed linear models to analyze repeated measurements in cohorts and general linear regression models for cross-sectional studies.
Residential soil contamination in 2008 was highly correlated with the individual body burden of 137Cs. Serum IgG and IgM concentrations increased between 1993 and 1998. Children with higher 137Cs soil exposure had lower serum IgG levels, which, however, increased in the small cohort assessed between 1997 and 2010. Children within the fourth quintile of 137Cs soil exposure (266–310 kBq/m2) had higher IgM serum concentrations between 1993 and 1998 but these declined between 1997 and 2010. IgA remained stable with median 137Cs exposures related to higher IgA levels, which was corroborated in the cross-sectional study of 2008–2010. Specific IgE against indoor allergens was detected less often in children with higher 137Cs exposure.
Our findings show radiation-related alterations of immunoglobulins which by themselves do not constitute adverse health effects. Further investigations are necessary to understand how these changes affect health status.
As a result of the Chernobyl nuclear incident on April 26, 1986, the Narodichesky district (Jitomirsky region, Ukraine), located about 80 km west of Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant, was contaminated with different radionuclides. A predominant radionuclide was 137Cs with a half-life of 30 years. According to statistics from the only All-Ukrainian population census, 24 years after the Chernobyl catastrophe, the population of Narodichi consisted of approximately 11,400 people, including 2,000 children . The Narodichesky district is a farming area; its 137Cs soil contamination in 1992 varied between 59 and 879 kBq/m2 and in 2011 between 16 and 488 kBq/m2. The region covers 1284 square kilometers (diameter 60–80 km) and has the same whether, wind and climate conditions.
One of the important questions is whether radiation following the disaster affected immune responses. A report of the UN Chernobyl Forum stated that “reported immunological effects of radiation exposure from the Chernobyl incident appeared to be related to both changes in the amount or function of peripheral lymphocytes and changes in serum immunoglobulin levels” . Few studies have been conducted on the link between radiation and immune markers [4–13]. A recently published report  concluded that the immune status is imbalanced in children whose parents were evacuated as children from either the city Pripyat adjacent to the reactor or from the 30-km zone surrounding the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant (first zone) . Also, the immune system in children whose parents resided in the third and second zones was characterized by similar changes . A recent review  stated the need for further investigations into the long term effects of low dose 137Cs irradiation on the immune system. Our work herein focuses on immunoglobulins (Ig) A, G, M, and E in children from the Narodichesky district.
After the Chernobyl incident, serum levels of IgA in children aged 1–14 years varied with time and exposure. Within the first 1.5 months after the incident, in children 7–14 years residing in villages of Gomel and Mogilev, Belarus, with density of 137Cs soil contamination over 1 Ci/km2 (Note: 1 curie (Ci)/km2 = 37 kBq/m2), serum IgA was significantly higher compared to non-exposed controls [6, 9, 11] and returned back to normal levels within seven months . During the first six years after the Chernobyl incident serum IgA concentrations in children were slightly higher than in controls but did not exceed the normal limits . From 1986 to 1992 serum IgA levels decreased significantly in two groups with low to medium levels of soil contamination, 3.46 Ci/km2 (~128 kBq/m2) and 6.04 Ci/km2(~223 kBq/m2) . Similar changes were detected in children from Brest, Gomel, and Mogilev (Belarus) residing in areas with high levels of radiation (80–120 Ci/km2) nine years after the incident . Another study linked serum immunoglobulins to internal doses of 137Cs in children, accumulated over 14 years after the Chernobyl incident . In the study by Chebanenko et al.  whole body concentration (WBC) of 137Cs was measured in Bq using gamma-spectrometer (Whole Body Counter SKRINNER-3M). This measurement was used for calculation of the internal dose of 137Cs in mSv. According with their WBC, children were divided into 3 groups: I - 1,087-13,956 Bq (mean 4,540 ± 210 Bq), internal dose 0.150-1.147 mSv (mean 0.412, mSv); II - 1,046-10,060 Bq (mean 3,820 ± 260 Bq), internal dose 0.106-0.899 mSv (mean 0.209 mSv); III - 0–960 Bq (mean 410 ± 60 Bq), internal dose was not reported. Decreased levels of IgA occurred more frequently at higher internal doses. In summary, there is a lack of studies and inconsistent findings on whether long-term radiation exposure affects serum IgA concentrations.
Serum concentrations of IgG in children ages 7–14 years residing in villages of Gomel and Mogilev with soil density of 137Cs exceeding 1 Ci/km2 were significantly decreased within the first 45  and 90 days  after the Chernobyl incident. IgG concentrations returned to the level of unexposed controls within the following seven months . Serum levels of IgG in children ages 3–7 years residing in contaminated areas in Gomel and Mogilev, Belarus, started to increase a year after the incident . In agreement with this “suppressed-increased time pattern”, Titov et al (1995) reported for the same areas of Belarus that during the first six years after the incident, IgG serum concentrations in children 1–14 years of age increased over time, reached levels of the controls in 1990, and then exceeded them in 1992. From 1986 to 1992, serum levels of IgG were reported to be positively correlated with the levels of 137Cs soil contamination . Analysis of IgG subclasses during the phase of increase (1993) demonstrated that concentrations of IgG1 and IgG4 were positively correlated with 137Cs body burden whereas for the concentrations of IgG2 and IgG3 subclasses correlations were inversely associated . Fourteen years after the incident, the proportion of children with hypoimmunoglobulinemia G was 12.4% in the group with the lowest body burden (0–960 Bq), 14.3% in children with a body burden between 1,046 Bq and 10,060 Bq, and 11.1% in the highest group (1,087-13,956 Bq) . In summary, prior findings suggest that IgG seems to follow a “suppressed-increased time pattern” after the exposure to ionizing radiation.
During the first 1.5 months after the Chernobyl accident IgM serum levels in children 1–14 years residing in the Braginsky region of Belarus with a 137Cs soil contamination density of 3 Ci/km2 (111 kBq/m2) seemed to be slightly increased [7, 9]. However, another study with a larger sample (n = 6,000), showed that immediately after the fallout serum concentrations of IgM in children ages 7–14 years residing in villages of Gomel and Mogilev, Belarus, with density of soil contamination with 137Cs over 1 Ci/km2 started to decrease and were the lowest by day 30 and then recovered . By day 90 after the Chernobyl incident IgM levels exceeded the concentrations found in controls. In the same study, levels of serum IgM in children 1–14 years kept increasing during the first six years after the Chernobyl. Hence, in 1992 the levels were significantly higher than in controls in all age groups . Ten years after the incident, children 1–14 years with frequent respiratory infections residing in contaminated territories had elevated levels of IgM in serum and saliva . In children residing in Gomel and Mogilev, Belarus, levels of IgM were positively correlated with levels of 137Cs soil contamination . In another study conducted in Brest, Gomel and Mogilev, children residing in areas with radiation levels of 37–185 kBq/m2 had increased serum IgM; however, at high levels (2,960-4,400 kBq/m2) concentrations of IgM were decreased [5, 17]. Fourteen years after the Chernobyl incident, the proportion of children with IgM levels below clinical references positively correlated with internal 137Cs dose . In the same study, increased IgM levels were consistently observed in 10% of children and did not vary by the internal 137Cs dose. In summary, no clear response pattern of IgM after exposure to radiation was seen in prior studies.
IgE exists mostly in a bound state with mast cells located beneath the skin and mucosa. The binding of IgE with antigens causes degranulation of mast cells, which then can induce an allergic reaction. It was reported that between 1987–1995, approximately 40% of children residing in contaminated territories had increased levels of total IgE in serum [9, 18]. In 1993, concentrations of total IgE were 2–3 times higher than clinical standards . Between 1996 and 1999, in 12 children residing in contaminated areas with 137Cs in the soil 260–370 kBq/m2 serum IgE levels were significantly increased (mean > 485 IU/ml) compared to 108 control children from clean areas, with 137Cs soil levels of 0.037 kBq/m2 (mean: 108 IU/ml) . Concentrations of IgE antibodies to grass and birch pollen as well as total IgE levels were reported to be positively correlated with the soil levels of 137Cs [6–9]. Hence, it seems that long term exposure to ionizing radiation after the Chernobyl incident may result in higher IgE levels in children residing in contaminated areas. However, the prior studies did not take into account confounders such as cat and dog exposure that may be associated with the exposure to 137Cs in the soil and may affect serum IgE levels.
Findings describing serum levels of IgA, G, M, and E in children residing in 137Cs- contaminated areas are not directly comparable since they present changes occurring at different times after the nuclear incident, use either different laboratory tests for immunoglobulins [6, 8] or do not report which tests were used [12, 17, 19], involve children of different age, use different exposure measures such as 137Cs soil levels or body burdens, and define exposures in different ways. We did not identify any studies characterizing immunoglobulins in children of different age who remained in the contaminated territories for a longer period of time. To enhance our knowledge about effects of radiation on the immune system, we investigated associations between long term exposure to 137Cs and levels of IgA, G, M and E in various cohorts and samples of children who resided in the Narodichesky district, Ukraine, for longer periods of time.
Our investigation focused on three distinct study groups: 1) a dynamic cohort, 2) two cross-sectional samples, and 3) a longitudinal cohort (Figure 1). We consider this dynamic cohort investigation a natural experiment because the entire population was randomly exposed to radiation, although the exposure allocation was not controlled by the investigators. There are no differences in climate, temperature, wind, or other weather conditions between the villages in this area that may have affected the fall-out. Additionally, the fall-out was not related to differences in the resident population, occupation, or living conditions. Following the Chernobyl nuclear incident people residing in surrounding regions were exposed to different levels of ionizing radiation emitted by 137Cs and other radionuclides in a relatively random distribution independent of other social, physical, behavioral, and genetic risk factors. In addition, this is a dynamic cohort since not all children participated in all years; new children entered and older ones left the cohort due to reaching adulthood. The cohort is described in detail elsewhere [13, 20]. The dynamic cohort comprises 616 children 3–16 years of age with repeated medical exams between 1993 and 1998.
To investigate changes in immunoglobulins between 1997–1998 and 2008–2010, we compared two cross-sectional analyses with different participants who were assessed at a similar age. The first cross-sectional subsample consists of 424 participants of the mentioned above dynamic cohort (421 were 8–17 years old) who had last physical examination in 1997–1998 and measurements of serum IgA, G and M (cross-sectional sample 1997–1998). The second cross-sectional subsample includes 650 children from the Narodichesky region examined in 2008–2010 (2008–2010 cross-sectional sample); of these, 523 children were 8–17 years of age. In the 2008–2010 cross-sectional sample we measured IgE for the first time and collected additional information on smoking exposure history, household exposures, asthma, eczema and rhinitis. Lastly, we identified a sample of 25 participants who were examined in 1997–1998 and reexamined 11 years later, in 2008–2010, and had measurements of IgA, G and M in both physical examinations (longitudinal study). In this cohort we can identify individual changes based on two measurements, 11 years apart.
Assessment of exposure to 137Cs
The residential soil contamination levels of 137Cs were used as a proxy of a child’s exposure to 137Cs. The most important radioactive isotope is 137Cs, which is formed by nuclear fission, has a half-life of 30 years and emits beta and gamma radiation. Dosimetric assessments of settlements in Ukraine contaminated with radionuclides were published from 1991 to 2005 in 10 reports . In addition, the Ministry of Emergency Situations provided spatial data on radiation contamination in the soil [22, 23]. These values were used for exposure assessment for the dynamic cohort (1993–1998). For children examined in 2008–2010, data on soil, cow milk, and potato concentrations of 137Cs in the various locations were obtained from the report by the Ukrainian Ministry of Emergency Situations  and from the Ministry of Health of Ukraine . For the cross-sectional subsamples (1997–1998 and 2008–2010) 137Cs soil contamination was grouped into quintiles previously established for the dynamic cohort of 1993–1998 . Identical cut-off points, also established for the 1993–1998 investigation , were applied to categorize the soil contamination for the 25 participants of the longitudinal cohort.
In addition to residential soil contamination levels of 137Cs, the individual whole-body burden of 137Cs was measured in 2008–2010 with a gamma-spectrometer Whole Body Counter “SCRINNER-3M”, designed and produced by INECO (Ukrainian Institution of Human Ecology, Academy of Technological Sciences), and used for mass screenings in 12 medical centers of the Ukraine . The technical characteristics of “SCRINNER-3M”, calibration and measurement protocol were described in detail elsewhere . To preserve the longitudinal comparisons of the samples, we only used individual whole-body count of 137Cs for comparison of exposure measures. The body burden of 137Cs was adjusted for weight (kg) . Because of known variations with season of quantification [28, 29], we also took the month of measurement into account. After adjustment for weight, month, age, and gender of the child in linear models using log-transformed whole-body 137Cs, we estimated the residuals. For the residuals, which do not yet contain the effect of residential exposure, we tested their correlation with levels of 137Cs soil contamination (kBq/m2) and cow milk contamination (Bq/L).
Measurements of immunoglobulins A, G, M, and E
In participants examined between 1993 and 1998 concentrations of immunoglobulins A, G, and M were determined in fasting serum samples collected in EDTA tubes using reverse radial immunodiffusion (Mancini technique). In participants examined in 2008–2010, total concentrations of IgA, G, and M in morning fasting serum samples were analyzed using enzyme immunoassay (RT 2100C Microplate Reader, Rayto, China) with ELISA immunokits Serazym IgG, IgM and IgA (Seramun Diagnostica GmbH, Berlin, Germany). To compare the Mancini technique and enzyme immunoassay, we measured total serum levels of IgA, G, and M in 20 children using both methods and calculated intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) . ICCs showed high comparability of the two methods: IgA: 0.99, IgG: 0.95, and IgM: 0.98. Concentrations of antigen-specific IgE in participants examined in 2008–2010 were analyzed using Alpha Rapid test (Dr. Fooke Laboratorien GmbH, Neuss and Neuruppin, Germany). We used two mixtures of the most common allergens: indoor (Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus, Dermatophagoides farina, Aspergillus fumigates, Aspergillus niger, cat and dog dander) and outdoor (seasonal weeds and flowers). Due to budgetary constraints, IgE could only be measured in 180 of the 523 children 8–17 years of age.
In the 2008–2010 investigation, we collected information about additional potential confounders, since behavioral adjustment to the accident may have been different in groups with different random allocation of radiation. Data included exposure to tobacco smoke at home, active smoking, and antibiotic use in the last 12 months, exposure to cats and dogs living in a household, exposure to coke, coal, wood and gas used for fueling the stove for heating and cooking. Information about asthma-, rhinitis- and eczema-like symptoms was obtained during the interview using the Russian version of the standardized International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC) questionnaire . For asthma, we elicited information about the following symptoms within 12 months prior to the interview: wheezing/whistling, wheezing attacks, sleep disturbances due to wheezing/whistling, and wheezing during/after physical activity. Regarding rhinitis in the last 12 months, data was collected on sneezing/running nose/nasal congestion not related to cold, nose problems accompanied by itchy-watery eyes, and information on whether nose problem interfered with daily activities. For eczema, we gathered answers about itchy rash in the last 12 months and whether it manifested in the folds of the elbows, behind the knees, in front of the ankles, under the buttocks, or around the neck, ears or eyes; whether the rash had cleared completely at any time during the last 12 months; and whether the child had been kept awake at night by this itchy rash in the last 12 months. For each manifestation, the sum of positive answers was scored: zero, one and 2–4 symptoms.
We used four different epidemiological approaches (Figure 1): a dynamic cohort, two cross-sectional studies, and a small longitudinal study. For the dynamic cohort (1993–1998) and the small longitudinal study (from 1997–1998 to 2008–2010), linear mixed models  were employed to analyze the effect of residential soil levels of 137Cs on repeated measurements of IgA, G and M. To adjust the repeated measurements for within-participant effects, we used the regular maximum likelihood method and started with an unstructured covariance matrix, which requires the least amount of constraints. An autoregressive covariance matrix significantly improved the model fit based on the evaluation of Akaike information and Bayesian Schwarz information criteria . The analysis of the dynamic cohort (1993–1998) concentrated on four main effects (soil contamination, child’s gender, child’s age, and year of the exam) and the interaction between year and soil contamination. We used quintiles of 137Cs soil contamination developed in 2008 .
The same categories were used for the longitudinal cohort of 25 participants, however, without the highest exposure levels. For this small sample we applied mixed linear models to analyze the two repeated measurements.
For the cross-sectional analyses of data for 1997–1998 and 2008–2010, we used linear regression models to assess the association between quintiles of soil contamination and IgA, IgG, IgM, and adjusted for child’s gender and age at the time of the physical examination. In addition, in the cross-sectional analysis 2008–2010, we adjusted for household and individual characteristics. All data analyses were performed using SAS software (Version 9.2: Statistical Analysis System, Cary, NC).
Immunoglobulin levels typically increase until the age of 11 years and then remain at a comparable level thereafter . Hence, in the two cross-sectional studies, we stratified children into two age groups: 8–11 and 12–17 years, which allows us to compare corresponding groups in the two cross-sectional analyses. In the cross-sectional analysis of the 1997–1998 data we controlled for child’s age, gender, and year of investigation using general linear regression models. For the 2008–2010 data, we considered additional adjustment for exposure to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS), active smoking, antibiotic use, exposure to cats and dogs, and coal, coke, wood or gas used as a fuel in stoves for heating and cooking. Age was used as a categorical variable to take possible nonlinear effects into account. Children were considered exposed to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) if they had direct or parental exposure to ETS at home, or if either parent was identified as a smoker. For children 12–17 years of age, we calculated the average number of cigarettes per day smoked by each child and categorized the variable into three groups: nonsmokers, 10 cigarettes per day or less, more than 10 cigarettes per day. Frequency of antibiotic use during the 12 months prior to the physical examination was grouped: no use, one time, two or more times. For exposures to cats and dogs living in the household we used three groups: none, cat/dog living outside and not allowed in the house, cat/dog living in the house or living outside but allowed to come inside. Exposure to coke, coal, and wood used as a fuel in the stove for heating or cooking was combined in one variable (yes/no). Exposure to gas fumes produced during cooking or heating was treated as a separate variable (yes/no). Regarding allergic manifestations, the sum of asthma-, rhinitis- and eczema-like symptoms was scored: zero, one and 2–4 symptoms. Confounding was assessed using 10% rule; i.e., a potential confounder was kept in the explanatory model if its removal changed the estimate between exposure and immunoglobulin by more than 10%.
From the comparison of the two cross-sectional studies it is obvious that children examined in 1997–1998 were comparable with children examined in 2008–2010 in regard to gender (51% versus 49% were female) and median age (12 versus 14 years, Table 1). The distribution of the 137Cs soil contamination changed considerably between 1997–1998 and 2008–2010. In 1997–1998, 39.6% resided in areas with the highest level of soil contamination (350 kBq/m2 and above). In 2008–2010, most children lived in areas with medium levels of soil contamination (165–265 kBq/m2). Only one child came from the area with the second highest soil contamination level (266–349 kBq/m2); this child was included in the medium exposure group. This led to three exposure levels for the years 2008–2010. The proportion of children in areas with the lowest soil contamination (<116 kBq/m2) increased only by 3.4% in 2008–2010. Overall, the median soil exposure in children did not decrease. The mean serum concentrations of IgA, IgG and IgM in children 8–17 years in the cross-sectional study 2008–2010 were 1.86 g/l, 11.6 g/l and 1.14 g/l, respectively.
Soil contamination values in 2008–2010 were only estimates based on measurements taken in 1992 and a decay function. Hence, to corroborate our findings for the exams in 2008–2010, we also used radiation levels in cow milk samples (Bq\L) collected in 2008 in different villages (n = 25; milk samples were collected yearly). Both soil contamination and cow milk samples from the different villages were strongly correlated (r = 0.7, p <0.0001, n = 25) which increases credibility of estimated soil exposure. In addition, using individual measurements of whole-body burden of 137Cs (continuous, Bq) in a linear regression model we adjusted for age (years), gender, weight (kg) and month of measurement, and determined the residuals. These were normally distributed. Then, the residuals of these individual measurements (not explained by residential exposure) were correlated with the area 137Cs soil contamination (kBq/m2). Indeed, the correlation in 26 villages was high (r = 0.64, Figure 2). Finally, using the same approach, we correlated the residuals of the individual whole-body burden of 137Cs with the radiation values in milk (Bq\L) for 2008. The correlation coefficient was lower (0.42, p = 0.04, 25 villages).
In the dynamic cohort, 617 children had repeated measurements between 1993–1998, providing 2,407 measurements of IgA, IgG, and IgM. In mixed linear models we predicted mean levels of each immunoglobulin (the outcome) based on quintiles of 137Cs soil contamination (the exposure) and adjusted for gender and age of the child, year of the exam, and the interaction between year and soil contamination. Regarding IgA, the highest and the lowest exposure groups (≥350 kBq/m2 and 29–112 kBq/m2, respectively) had the lowest immunoglobulin levels (Figure 3). Children in three groups with a median soil exposure had the highest IgA serum concentration. For IgA, the main effect of soil radiation and its interaction with the year of the exam were statistically significant (p = 0.034 and p = 0.039, respectively, Table 2). The lowest and two medium exposure groups (29–112 kBq/m2, 116–134 kBq/m2 and 165–253 kBq/m2, respectively) had very similar serum IgG concentrations which gradually increased over time. The lowest serum IgG level was observed in the group with the highest 137Cs soil contamination 350–879 kBq/m2. In the second highest exposure group (266–310 kBq/m2), serum IgG level dipped in 1995 and in 1997 exceeded levels for all other groups. For IgG, the interaction term between soil contamination and year were also statistically significant (p = 0.001). Regarding IgM, the highest serum IgM levels were in the third exposure group (266–310 kBq/m2; Figure 3). Although the interaction term between level of soil irradiation and year is statistically significant (p = 0.02), all exposure groups seem to show increased IgM serum concentrations over time (Figure 3).
While for the dynamic cohort (1993–1998) we assumed random allocation of radiation (natural experiment), for the children examined in 2008–2010 we needed to test whether potential risk factors differed in the three remaining exposure categories. Since immunoglobulins increase until age 11 years, we stratified the analysis by age (8–11, 12–17 years, Table 3). In both age strata, the frequency of antibiotic use within the last 12 months prior to physical examination did not differ among the exposure groups with various 137Cs soil contamination. In addition, we tested whether IgA, IgG, or IgM serum concentrations co-varied with antibiotic use in the last 12 months and found no association (data not shown). Antibiotic use was not confounding the association between residential exposures and immunoglobulins. Table 3 shows that children 8–11 years of age in the lowest 137Cs soil contamination category had significantly higher proportions of dogs and stoves fueled with coal, coke or wood in their households (Table 3). Similar findings were seen in the age-group 12–17 years. In addition, active smoking was significantly higher in older children residing in areas with the lowest 137Cs soil contamination (12.3% vs. 7.3%). Hence, it seems that there were potential confounders that could mask the 137Cs soil exposure and as a result multivariate adjustment was necessary.
Using general linear models, we did not find statistically significant associations between categorized 137Cs soil contamination and immunoglobulin levels in the cross-sectional analyses of the 1997–1998 data (data not shown). However, in children 8–11 years of age examined in 2008–2010 after adjustment for age, gender, and environmental smoke exposure, the mean level of IgA was significantly higher in the 137Cs soil contamination category of 165–265 kBq/m2, representing the median exposure group of the 1993–1998 investigations (Table 4). In these children, levels of IgA were also significantly positively correlated with the levels of 137Cs in locally produced cow milk adjusted for the same confounders. In children aged 12–17 years, there was no significant association between soil contamination levels of 137Cs and IgA (data not shown). Immunoglobulins M and G were not associated with soil contamination levels of 137Cs in age group 8–11, nor in group 12–17 (data not shown).
In the 2008–2010 cross-sectional study, specific IgE for mixtures of specific indoor and outdoor allergens were measured in a subsample of 180 children. Cross-tabulation of IgE reactions with 137Cs soil contamination did not detect any positive response in the exposure category of 116–164 kBq/m2, which was therefore combined with the 165–265 kBq/m2 category. Controlling for age, gender, dog and cat exposure, in logistic regression analyses, IgE responses to indoor allergens were statistically significantly lower in children residing in the 116–265 kBq/m2 area (p = 0.013, Table 5). There was no statistically significant difference for IgE specific to outdoor allergens.
To explore whether other factors influence immunoglobulins, we investigated three symptom groups of allergic sensitization manifesting as asthma-like, rhinitis-like and eczema-like symptoms in children ages 8–17 examined in 2008–2010 (n = 523). We did not detect any association between 137Cs soil contamination and the symptom groups since asthma-like (1.7%), eczema-like (3.6%) and rhinitis-like symptoms (3.5%) were reported only for a few children. Having symptoms from any of the three groups was not related to changes in immunoglobulins A, G, and M.
The follow-up study of 25 participants (longitudinal cohort) examined in 1997–1998 and reexamined in 2008–2010 allowed us to investigate changes in immunoglobulins A, G, and M in a small longitudinal sample. The age range at the first medical exam was 8–15 and 19–27 years in the second. The median soil contamination level of 137Cs decreased from 224 to 171 kBq/m2 (Table 1). Due to the small sample size, we considered only three exposure levels (29–112 kBq/m2, 116–165, and > 265 kBq/m2). In 1997–1998, 4, 5, and 16 children were in the three respective groups; in 2008–2010 the numbers were 8, 4, and 13.
In this longitudinal cohort, serum IgA levels did not change. The individual plots of IgG for 25 longitudinal observations over 11 years showed substantial dynamics: the lower levels seemed to increase and the higher to decrease (Additional file 1). The result of mixed linear regression revealed that in the higher exposure groups, IgG increased from time 1 (1998–1997) to time 2 (2008–2010) from approximately 9.5 g/ml to approximately 14 g/L (Table 6). It remained more stable in the low exposure group (approximately 13.1 g/L and 11.9 g/L). On the contrary, IgM decreased in the group of children to adults with the highest residential exposure (165–364 kBq/m2) from 1.36 g/L to 0.94 g/L and remained more stable in the other two groups.
Interestingly, between 1993 and 1998, IgM levels particularly in the two highest exposure groups (266–310 and 350–879 kBq/m2) increased (Figure 3, sample size n = 617). However, in the small longitudinal cohort (n = 25) with measurements in 1997–1998 and 2008–2010, IgM levels decreased in the highest exposure group (165–253 kBq/m2). The latter group had the least increase from 1993–1989 (Figure 3). However, both trends may not be comparable since the age in the 1993–1998 cohort was 1–17 years and in the longitudinal cohort it was 8–15 years at the first medical exam and 19–27 years in the second.
Our data suggest that immunoglobulins were still affected 6–12 years after the nuclear incident and remained affected more than 20 years later. There is no clear linear pattern, but various convex-curve-like associations. IgA appears to be higher in children with the medium exposure level (dynamic cohort 1993–1998) compared to children with lower and higher exposures (convex curve). IgG seems to gradually increase in children with lower exposure levels (dynamic cohort and longitudinal cohort), however, in two groups with the highest exposure, IgG first declines and then increases approximately 9 years after the incident. IgM was also found to be higher in the medium exposure groups (dynamic cohort) and lower in children with the higher residential exposure (longitudinal cohort). IgE specific to indoor allergens was lower in children with higher residential exposure.
Using various approaches, we attempted to establish and analyze follow-up data of the Narodichi Children Cohort (NCC) from 1993 to 2010. We used 137Cs soil contamination levels, which were available for all investigations between 1993 and 2010. The availability facilitates comparisons over time; however, the disadvantage of using spatial exposure assessments is that it may result in less precision compared to measurements in individuals. Adding to this uncertainty, we realized that the levels documented after 1992 were estimated based on measurements in 1992 and the decay function (137Cs: half-life of 30 years) and not actual measurements. Nevertheless, among 26 villages where children had whole body counts, the individual and the soil radiation levels (2008) correlated reasonably well (r = 0.64). A comparable correlation (r = 0.7) was reported in the past . Radiation in cow milk from different villages was measured repeatedly since 1992. The residuals of individual measurements, after adjusting for age, body weight, and month of measurement, and the radiation concentration in cow milk were also correlated (r = 0.42). Given the residential stability of the children and the lack of individual measurements before 2008, soil measurements in various villages seem to constitute acceptable radiation exposure assessments and have the advantage of long-term comparability, which is needed to evaluate changes in outcome variables.
In the dynamic cohort 1993–1998, for all immunoglobulins, A, G and M, a similar secular trend was observed with dip or plateau around 1995 and consequent increase over time (Figure 3). Reduced levels in 1995 may be related to changes in supply of radiation-free food provided by the Ukrainian government to residents of radionuclide contaminated areas after the Chernobyl incident. In 1995, due to deteriorated financial situation, the Ukrainian government stopped delivery of uncontaminated food to the residents, and radionuclide-free meals at schools were reduced down to two per day. As a consequence, the residents increased their consumption of locally grown produce and forest goods contaminated with 137Cs. Technical causes that might contribute to these changes are unlikely, since during this period, laboratory analyses were conducted by the same personnel using the same techniques.
For the dynamic cohort 1993–1998, we discovered that the serum IgA concentrations did not change much over time; children residing in areas with medium level of 137Cs soil contamination (116–310 kBq/m2) had higher IgA serum concentrations compared to children in villages with lower (<116 kBq/m2) and higher (>350 kBq/m2) exposure levels (convex-curve-like association). The main function of IgA is neutralization of antigens on mucous membranes including gastro-intestinal tract . We hypothesize that higher serum levels of IgA in medium exposure groups as compared to low exposure may reflect an increased response of the immune system to 137Cs ingested with locally produced food, which is now considered the main way how 137Cs enters human body [36, 37]. On the contrary, exposure to higher levels of radiation may have slightly decreased the immune response; therefore, the levels of serum IgA in these children were lower than in all other exposure groups and in agreement with the previous studies [5, 6]. The findings in the dynamic cohort 1993–1998 were corroborated in the 2008–2010 data in children 8–11 years. Children residing in areas with a soil contamination level of 165–265 kBq/m2 (medium exposure group in 1993–1998 cohort and the highest in 2008–2010) and consuming cow milk with higher 137Cs levels (>85 Bq/L) had higher levels of serum IgA as compared to the lowest exposure levels even 25 years after the incident. This is in agreement with investigations conducted in Belarus  and in residents of villages located on the riverbanks of the Techa River . The Techa River was contaminated as a result of radioactive releases by a plutonium production facility in 1949–1956. Residents with continuous exposure to ionizing radiation showed significant increase in serum levels of IgA at all levels of dose without a definite trend. Our findings further agreed with the analysis of yearly measured radiation levels in cow milk (Bq/L) from the different villages, indicating a convex-curve-like association.
Regarding IgG and IgM, we found a significant increase in all residential exposure groups between 1993 and 1998 which is in agreement with the previous prospective study that evaluated serum immunoglobulin levels in children residing in contaminated areas of Belarus between 1986 and 1992 . The longitudinal comparison of a small group of 25 participants between 1997–1998 and 2008–2010 showed that in participants with higher exposures, IgG levels increased, and IgM levels decreased in the highest exposure group (165–364 KBq/m2). The higher concentrations of IgG in serum in response to continuous exposure to low-dose ionizing radiation might be explained by inherent features of IgG. Due to its small size, IgG easily diffuses into tissues, opsonizes pathogens for engulfment by phagocytes, activates the complement system, and neutralizes antigens . We speculate that IgG may be involved in neutralization of 137Cs which passed through the intestinal mucosa into the systemic circulation and reached tissues. Regarding IgM, the largest among the immunoglobulins and the first one to interact with new antigens , we speculate that in children exposed to 137Cs for a long period of time, the serum IgM levels could have been affected by decreased immune response.
We believe that selection bias did not distort our findings. After the Chernobyl nuclear incident all children residing in the Narodichesky district of Zhitomir Oblast, Ukraine, were obligated by law to participate in yearly health screenings, although it was never enforced. The incentive to participate in the screening was free hospital treatment at the Research Center for Radiation Medicine (Kyiv, Ukraine) provided to children with health problems. The trust and the excellent rapport between the team of physicians from the Research Center for Radiation Medicine and the pediatric clinic in the Narodichi hospital facilitated eager participation. All children from remote villages were transported by bus to the pediatric clinic in Narodichi. It is possible that a small number of sick children were not able to attend the screening.
Regarding immunoglobulins, the agreement between two measurements of immunoglobulins used between 1993 and 1998 and in 2008–2010 is high. Hence, there is no indication of a differential information bias.
Since in a prior report we found obstructive and restrictive lung function changes in the NCC , we added measurements of specific IgE against indoor and outdoor allergens to the set of clinical examinations conducted in 2008–2010. To our surprise we found that IgE specific against indoor allergens, but not outdoor allergens, was statistically significantly less frequent in children residing in villages with higher soil concentrations. In addition, the frequency of asthma-like (1.7%), eczema-like (3.6%), and rhinitis-like (3.5%) symptoms in children of the NCC is low compared to northern and eastern European Countries . Similar differences in the prevalence of these symptoms have been reported between the Finnish and Russian Karelia . Except for ‘western lifestyle’ no substantial explanation has been offered to explain this divergence. Of interest, is that these results suggest that allergic sensitization (positive specific IgE) against indoor allergen mix, but not outdoor allergens (pollen), is negatively associated with 137Cs soil contamination levels (OR = 0.02; 95%CI 0.05-0.71). It may be possible, that 137Cs radiation reduces the population of mite and mold species, reducing the indoor allergen but not outdoor allergen burden and thus the respective sensitization. This explanation is supported by findings that microorganisms in the feathers of birds in the Chernobyl region may be reduced by radiation .
Effects of low-level radiation on the humoral immune system are detectable 20 years after the nuclear incident in Chernobyl (1986). Thousands of peasant children live in areas where the soil is still profoundly contaminated with 137Cs and consume locally grown foods. Surprisingly, higher soil radiation levels were related to fewer indoor allergen sensitizations (specific IgE), a finding, that needs to be replicated in future studies. The changes in the immunoglobulins cannot be seen as indication of increased risks leading to the manifestation of known adverse health effects, but should be considered as compensatory mechanisms in children coping with low-level radiation. There is a need to understand whether these compensatory mechanisms may fail, which could lead to adverse health effects. In addition, following the analyses of humoral immune responses, cellular immune responses and their interplay need to be analyzed. In summary, the results of this study point to the need for further surveillance, scientific evaluation, and continued environmental remediation.
Degree of freedom
Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay
Environmental tobacco smoke
Intraclass correlation coefficient
Ukrainian Institution of Human Ecology, Academy of Technological Sciences
International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood
Narodichi Children Cohort.
All-Ukrainian population census '2001. http://2001.ukrcensus.gov.ua/eng/results/general/urban-rural/Zhytomyr/. Accessed 05/13/2014.
Ministry of Health of the Ukraine: Certification doses for the settlements of Ukraine located in contaminated territories after the Chernobyl accident. Data for 2011. 2012, Kiev
Bennett B, Repacholi M, Carr Z: Report of the UN Chernobyl Forum Expert Group “Health”. Health Effects of the Chernobyl Accident and Special Health Care Programmes. 2006, Geneva: WHO Press, [http://www.who.int/ionizing_radiation/chernobyl/WHO%20Report%20on%20Chernobyl%20Health%20Effects%20July%2006.pdf] accessed 05/13/2014.
Verenich G: Health status of rural schoolchildren from Byelorussian Polesye: twenty-years shifts. Stud Hum Ecol. 1992, 10: 155-163.
Gurmanchuk I, Tytov LP, Kharytonik GD, Kozlova NA: Comparative characteristics of immune status of sick children in Gomel, Mogilev and Brest provinces [in Russian]. Proceedings of the Third Congress of Belarusian Scientific Society on Immunology and Allergology Actual Problems of Immunology and Allergy (Abstracts). 1995, Grodno, 79-80.
Titov LP, Kharitonic GD, Gourmanchuk IE, Ignatenko SI: Effects of radiation on the production of immunoglobulins in children subsequent to the Chernobyl disaster. Allergy Proc. 1995, 16: 185-193. 10.2500/108854195778666838.
Kharytonik G, Tytov LP, Gurmanchik IE, Ignatenko SI: Proceedings of Scientific and Practical Conference Remote Consequences of Irradiation for Immune and Blood Formation Systems: 7–10 May 1996. Scientific and Practical Conference Remote Consequences of Irradiation for Immune and Blood Formation Systems May 7–10, 1996. 1996, Kiev, 59-60.
Kyril’chik EY: Characteristics of immune status and immune rehabilitation of children living in radioactive contaminated territories: Clinical laboratory studies 1996–1999 [in Russian]. M.D. Thesis. 2000, Minsk: Minsk Medical Institute
Titov LP: Children’s Immune System Reaction to the Impact of Radiation as Result of the Chernobyl Accident [in Russian]. 2000, Minsk: Institute of Radiation Medicine
Vykhovanets EV, Chernyshov VP, Sluvkin II, Antipkin YG, Vasyuk A, Colos V: Analysis of blood lymphocyte subsets in children living around Chernobyl exposed long-term to low doses of cesium-137 and various doses of iodine-131. Radiat Res. 2000, 153: 760-772. 10.1667/0033-7587(2000)153[0760:AOBLSI]2.0.CO;2.
Titov LP: Early and remote consequences of Chernobyl Factors in the immune systems of children [in Russian]. Biological effects of low doses radiation Informational Bulletene. 2002, Minsk: Belarus Committee for Chernobyl Children
Chebanenko LO, Talko VV, Jakovleva GM: Clinical and functional characteristics of children and adolescents resident of radioactively contaminated regions during rehabilitation at Trouskavetz resort [in Ukrainian]. Проблеми радїацїйної медицини та радїобїологїї. 2004, 123-129.
Stepanova E, Karmaus W, Naboka M, Vdovenko V, Mousseau T, Shestopalov VM, Vena J, Svendsen E, Underhill D, Pastides H: Exposure from the Chernobyl accident had adverse effects on erythrocytes, leukocytes, and, platelets in children in the Narodichesky region, Ukraine: a 6-year follow-up study. Environ Health. 2008, 7: 21-10.1186/1476-069X-7-21.
Ministry of Ukraine of Emergencies: Twenty-five years after Chornobyl accident: safety for the future. 2011, Kyiv: KIM, Available at: http://www.inaco.co.jp/isaac/shiryo/genpatsu/chornobyl25eng.pdf. Accessed 05/05/2014
Verkhovna Rada of the Ukrainian SSR: On the status and social protection of citizens affected by the Chernobyl disaster [in Ukrainian]. [http://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/796-12]. Accessed 05/05/2014
Yablokov AV: 5. Nonmalignant diseases after the Chernobyl catastrophe. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2009, 1181: 58-160. 10.1111/j.1749-6632.2009.04822.x.
Galitskaya NN, Khmelevskaya LA, Zhuk GM, Vorontsova TV: Estimation of the immunological status of the children from the areas with the abnormal radiation [in Russian]. Belarusian Public Health. 1990, 6: 33-35.
Titov LP, Kharitonic GD, Gurmanchuk IE, Semenenia IN, Ignatenko SI, Kozlova NA, Levkovic MA: The reaction of the children immune system to the radiation resulting from the accident at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant [In Russian]. State of Hematopoietic and Immune System in Children in Belarus after the Chernobyl Disaster. 1996, Minsk: Minsk, 116-137.
Gnedko TV, Petrova AM: Peculiarities of hemato-immunologic status of new born children residing in regions of Republic Belarus, contaminated with radionuclides [in Russian]. Proceedings of Scientific and Practical Conference Remote Consequences of Irradiation for Immune and Blood Formation Systems: 7–10 May 1996. 1996, Kiev, 60-61.
Svendsen ER, Kolpakov IE, Stepanova YI, Vdovenko VY, Naboka MV, Mousseau TA, Mohr LC, Hoel DG, Karmaus WJ: 137 Cesium exposure and spirometry measures in Ukrainian children affected by the Chernobyl nuclear incident. Environ Health Perspect. 2010, 118: 720-725. 10.1289/ehp.0901412.
Ministry of Health of the Ukraine: Certification doses for the settlements of Ukraine located in contaminated territories after the Chernobyl accident. Reports # 1 to 7 and 9 and 10. 2005, Kiev
Ministry of Emergency Situations of Ukraine: Radiological status of areas included into zones contaminated with radiation (by region) [in Ukrainian]. 2008, Kiev: VETA Holding Group, Ltd.
Ministry of Emergency Situations of Ukraine: Atlas of radioactive contamination of Ukraine. 2011, Kiev: Intelligence Systems GEO
Ministry of Health of the Ukraine: Certification doses for the settlements of Ukraine radioactively contaminated after the Chernobyl nuclear accident. Data for 2008. Report # 13. 2009, Kiev
Perevoznikov OM, Vasylenko VV, Litvinetz LA, Yakovleva GN: Mass many years WBC-monitoring of Ukrainian inhabitants involved Chernobyl NPP accident [Abstract in English]. Radiatn Hyg. 2009, 2: 40-47.
Lindgren A, Stepanova E, Vdovenko V, McMahon D, Litvinetz O, Leonovich E, Karmaus W: Individual whole body concentration of 137Cesium is associated with decreased blood counts in children in the Chernobyl contaminated areas, Ukraine, 2008–2010. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol. 2013, doi:10.1038/jes.2013.60 [Epub ahead of print]
Morita N, Takamura N, Ashizawa K, Shimasaki T, Yamashita S, Okumura Y: Measurement of the whole-body 137Cs in residents around the Chernobyl nuclear power plant. Radiat Prot Dosimetry. 2005, 113: 326-329. 10.1093/rpd/nch457.
Hoshi M, Konstantinov YO, Evdeeva TY, Kovalev AI, Aksenov AS, Koulikova NV, Sato H, Takatsui T, Takada J, Endo S, Shibata Y, Yamashita S: Radiocesium in children residing in the western districts of the Bryansk Oblast from 1991–1996. Health Phys. 2000, 79: 182-186. 10.1097/00004032-200008000-00011.
Sekitani Y, Hayashida N, Karevskaya IV, Vasilitsova OA, Kozlovsky A, Omiya M, Yamashita S, Takamura N: Evaluation of (137)Cs body burden in inhabitants of Bryansk Oblast, Russian Federation, where a high incidence of thyroid cancer was observed after the accident at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant. Radiat Prot Dosimetry. 2010, 141: 36-42. 10.1093/rpd/ncq137.
Armstrong B, White E, Saracci R: Principles of Exposure Measurement in Epidemiology, Volume 21. 1992, Oxford, New York, Tokyo: Oxford University Press
Asher MI, Keil U, Anderson HR, Beasley R, Crane J, Martinez F, Mitchell EA, Pearce N, Sibbald B, Stewart AW, Strachan D, Weiland SK, Williams HC: International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC): rationale and methods. Eur Respir J. 1995, 8: 483-491. 10.1183/09031936.95.08030483.
Verbeke G, Molenberghs G: Linear mixed models for longitudinal data. 2000, New York: Springer
Behrman RE, Kliegman RM, Jenson HB: Nelson textbook of pediatrics. 2000, Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders Company
Sharifov VF, Koulikova NV, Voropai LV, Kroupnik TA, Masyakin VB, Cot VA, Kovalev AI, Aksenov AS, Averichev AA, Moiseyenko MY, Avramenko AI, Goncharenko OE, Daniliuk VV: Findings of the Chernobyl Sasakawa Health and Medical Cooperation Project: 137Cs concentration among children around Chernobyl. Chernobyl: A Decade Proceedings of the Fifth Chernobyl Sasakawa Medical Cooperation Symposium 1996. 1996, Kiev, Ukraine: Elsevier, 39-44.
Fagarasan S, Honjo T: Intestinal IgA synthesis: regulation of front-line body defenses. Nat Rev Immunol. 2003, 3: 63-72. 10.1038/nri982.
IAEA: Second revised version. Health, Environmental and Socio-economic Impacts and Recommendations to the Governments of Belarus, the Russian Federation and Ukraine. The Chernobyl Forum: 2003–2005. 2006, Austria: IAEA, [http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Booklets/Chernobyl/chernobyl.pdf]. Accessed 05/13/2014.
Korzun VN, Kurylo LV, Stepanova EI, Torbin VF: Ionizing radiation and nutrition in children. 1997, Kiev: Chernobilinterinform
Akleyev AV, Ovcharova EA: Characterization of immunity status in exposed residents of the Techa riverside villages 50 years after the onset of radiation exposure. Radiats Biol Radioecol. 2008, 48: 261-277.
Janeway C, Travers P: Immunobiology: the immune system in health and disease. 1997, New York: Garland Pub, 3
Laatikainen T, von Hertzen L, Koskinen JP, Makela MJ, Jousilahti P, Kosunen TU, Vlasoff T, Ahlstrom M, Vartiainen E, Haahtela T: Allergy gap between Finnish and Russian Karelia on increase. Allergy. 2011, 66: 886-892. 10.1111/j.1398-9995.2010.02533.x.
Czirjak GA, Moller AP, Mousseau TA, Heeb P: Microorganisms associated with feathers of barn swallows in radioactively contaminated areas around Chernobyl. Microb Ecol. 2010, 60: 373-380. 10.1007/s00248-010-9716-4.
Financial support for the health screenings was provided by the National Academy of Medical Sciences of Ukraine. This research was partially supported by a grant from the United States Civilian Research and Development Foundation (UKB1-2929-KV-08). The funding agency did not have any influence on the design, collection, analysis or interpretation of the data or writing the manuscript, nor did it affect the decision to submit the manuscript for publication.
The investigations were approved by the Committee on Bioethics of the Research Center of Radiation Medicine Academy Medicine of Sciences of Ukraine (Report #10, August 31, 2007) and by the Office of Research Compliance at the University of South Carolina.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
DM reviewed the literature, analyzed the data, drafted and revised the manuscript. WK obtained funding, developed the analytical plan, analyzed the data, and revised the manuscript. YS and VV designed the study protocol and conducted clinical examinations and blood analyses. VK designed questionnaire and conducted the interviews. ES analyzed the data and revised the manuscript. OL collected dosimetric information. All the authors approved the final version of the manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
McMahon, D.M., Vdovenko, V.Y., Karmaus, W. et al. Effects of long-term low-level radiation exposure after the Chernobyl catastrophe on immunoglobulins in children residing in contaminated areas: prospective and cross-sectional studies. Environ Health 13, 36 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1186/1476-069X-13-36
- Ionizing radiation